THE CONSERVATION AND RESTORATION OF TWO
POLYCHROMED
SCULPTURES
Audrone Davainiene, Laima Kruopaite*
Lithuanian Art Museum
P. Gudynas Restoration Centre
Rudninku str. 8, LT-2001 Vilnius,
Lithuania
The Baltic Nordic Conference on Conserved and Restored Works of Art 6-9
October 1999, Taliinn, Estonia. The Conservator as Investigator.
Tallinn, Conservation Centre Kanut, 2000. P. 69-72.
*
Author to whom correspondence should be addressed
 |
 |
|
Plate 7. The Crucifix by an unknown Lithuanian master, the second half
of the 19th century. Wood, polychromy. The Church of
Liškiava. The condition after the removal of the overpaintings. |
Plate 8. The Crucifix by an unknown Lithuanian master, the second half
of the 19th century. The condition |
 |
 |
| Plate 9. Madonna and Child by an unknown German master, 17th
century. Wood, polychromy. The Church of Vilkaviškis. The condition
before |
Plate 10. Madonna and Child by an unknown German master, 17th
century. The condition after restoration. |
Abstract
Two
sculptures conserved and restored in the P. Gudynas Restoration Centre,
Madonna and Child and Crucifix were made by artists of different epochs.
They came to the conservators considerably changed from their original
design. The Crucifix dated from the second half of the 19th century. It
is 160 cm in height, carved from alder-tree. A few overpainted layers
were coming off or crumbled in several places. The wood was strong and
not damaged by wood pests. Investigation revealed the sculpture's
original decoration, the manner of overpainting and composition of the
paint.
Three
coats of paint were taken off from the original polychrome mechanically
and using a solvent mixture. The open wood was primed and retouched. The
sculpture was covered with a protective coating. The crown of thorns and
the band were gilded.
The
sculpture of Madonna and Child was created by an unknown German artist
at the beginning of the 17th century. The sculpture was carved from a
single piece of wood and is 114 cm in height. A few attributes and small
fragments were missing. Almost one fourth of the polychromy had fallen
off and the rest was weakly attached. The wood was damaged by pests, but
was still solid. Investigation revealed that the sculpture was painted
five times. The original polychromy was established.
The
sculpture was disinfected. The wood and polychrome were strengthened and
the overpainting was removed. The missing fragments were carved. The
wood was primed and retouched with watercolours and gold and silver
leaf. The sculpture was covered with a protective coating. A full
reconstuction of the sculpture's paint layer was made, carefully saving
authentic polychrome pieces. This decision was made because of the
request of the Head of the Church.]
Keywords
polychrome sculpture, overpainting, conservation, restoration
The artists of ancient times used to be both creators and masters of
their craft. Their apprentices used to learn the craft first and only
having mastered it, the most talented of them began creating themselves.
While learning at the master's workshop and working together, the
apprentices would become acquainted with the whole process of creation,
the properties of materials used, the secrets of the craft and often
becoming well known masters. Thus during the Renaissance the same
painter often painted the walls of a church, polychromed sculptures and
decorated altars.
Wooden sculptures have been decorated from their beginnings:
polychromed, gilded and silvered. During the Gothic and Baroque periods
great attention was given to this matter and these works were
commissioned to the best artist.
With the change of epochs and style the character of the decoration
changed too. The predominating taste for beauty during the classicism
period could not compromise with the cheerful colourfulness of the
Gothic, Renaissance and Baroque. A one-colour decoration, imitating
light stone became fashionable. New sculptures were decorated in such
way and the surviving older ones were overpainted, adapting them to the
whole of new interior.
This occurred in Lithuania as well. Already during the Renaissance epoch
Lithuania was not a remote European province. Only later complicated
historical events made it one.
Plenty of surviving baroque sculptures hide their colorful polychromy
under later yellowish, gray one-colour overpaintings. They can be
restored after removing later overpaintings in the case when the
sculpture was overpainted without removing the old original
overpainting. The old polychromy together with the carving makes up the
authentic whole of the artwork. If the whole old polychrome was scraped
off down to the wood before repainting, it is impossible to reconstruct
the paint layer. The sculpture loses the essential part of its value as
the work of art of its time.
Because of temperature and moisture fluctuations, which are rather sharp
in our climatic zone, the timber begins "to walk" i.e. it expands and
shrinks more then the chalk glue priming and polychromy covering the
sculpture. In the course of time the priming and the paint layers become
loose from the support and begin to fall off.
The sculptures in churches are usually repainted not only when time
partly destroys the original polychromy but fashion and taste change.
They can be redecorated also after moving them into a new location and
sometimes directly during ordinary repairs. While painting walls and
floors, the saints' figures are also repainted so the works of art
change irrecognizably and the carving plasticity dis-appears under thick
layers of overpaint.
Two recently restored sculptures: Madonna and Child and Crucifix are
works of different periods and by artists of different countries. They
reached the restoration workshops significantly changed from their
original design. They changed under the influence of objective
(moisture) as well as subjective (the time period, fashion and owner's
taste) factors.
Conservator Audronė Davainienė had a complicated task: to return the
authentic appearance to the sculpture of Crucifix from the church of
Liškiava. Unfortunately, the present owners could not say anything about
the sculpture's origin and history. The art historians dated it from the
middle of the 19th century and this was later confirmed during the
analyses of the paint layers. It could also be the work of a local
artist. The Crucifix is of 160 cm in height, carved from alder-tree. The
head of Christ is surrounded with a rather massive thorn crown. The
perizone on the right hip is tied up in fanciful and pretentious knots.
The arms are carved separately. After having been broken they were
fastened with nails, which are now very rusty. Cavities formed because
of wood deformation and were filled with a cement mass, which was the
material found by a careless master. It could be seen that the sculpture
had been overpainted several times. The paint layers in many places
together with the ground were loose and had dropped off in places. The
front of the figure's shins was scratched down to the wood. A part of
the perizone's decoration was scratched, probably in an attempt seeking
to remove the overpaintings. The sculpture's timber was firm and not
damaged by wood pests. One lefthand finger was missing.
Samples were taken for polychrome stratigraphic and chemical research
from different places. After having carried out research, the original
polychromy and the character of overpaintings became clear. The white
pigment zinc white of the primary paint layer was used in painting in
the first half of the 19th c. and it was widely spread in the
middle of the century, replacing the toxic lead white. Thus, approximate
dating was possible. The research showed that the sculpture was primed
with a 0.3-0.6 mm thickness of grayish chalk- glue prime and the whole
sculpture was painted light, almost white, imitating stone, which was
characteristic for that period. The paint binder was oil. The thorn
crown and the perizone were gilded. Thus, having made the details clear,
the "white marble" sculpture became a reservedly decorative one.
The polychromy was overpainted three times. The body of Christ was
overpainted with reddish oil, later white emulsion and finally lime
paints. It seems, that the last paint layers, apparently, appeared while
the premises' walls together with the sculpture were painted. The gilded
fragments were repainted differently with green paint and with copper
powder.
The later over paintings were removed after having fastened the priming
and the loose polychromy. It was possible to scrape off the lime paint
layer with a scalpel mechanically without any greater difficulty. The
emulsion layer was washed off with a solvent mixture. The most
complicated part was the removal of the oil overpainting because it was
firmly bound together with the original paint layer. After having
removed the over paintings, the carving 's form became more vivid,
showing that the unknown sculptor had been not only a good expert at his
craft but a creator as well.
The flaking areas where the priming with the polychromy had fallen off
were covered with new chalk - glue ground and retouched with
watercolours. The sculpture was covered with a protective coating. The
original gilded layer of the thorn crown and the perizone had also been
destroyed and it was necessary to regild them with little gold leaves
preserving part of the old gilded surface. The regilding was carried out
by restorer Ieva Čiplyte (colour plates 7 and 8).
The Madonna and Child is a sculpture from the beginning of 17th c.,
belonging to a master from South Germany. This sculpture was designed
for an altar. It is of 114 cm in height, carved out of a single piece of
wood. The backside is not modelled but hollowed out only. The Madonna
and Child were originally crowned but only the Madonna's crown survived.
The Madonna had a sceptre in her left hand, the Child held the
terrestrial globe. Some fragments were missing as well:
the upper part of the Madonna's left sandal and the fourth and little
fingers of the Child's right arm. The Madonna's crown was too massive
and therefore the art historians had raised the hypothesis that it
probably had not been the author's intention and the sculpture was
crowned later. But the chemical analysis carried out on polychromy
showed that the sculpture and the Madonna's crown were done at the same
time.
The Madonna is standing upright, holding the Child in her left arm. The
Child's left arm is raised for blessing, a terrestrial globe is in the
Child's right arm. The globe was lost but it was not difficult to
establish its size from the garment's fold. The deepening for the crowns
was hollowed out on the vertices of both figures.
The sculpture's wood, though damaged by wood pests, is still rather
strong, though fractured, broken off in the places such as on the left
of Madonna's shoulder and the Child's right side. Apparently, seeking to
protect the wood from pests, the backside was painted over with a lime
mass.
A large part of the sculpture's polychromy, almost one fourth had flaked
off together with he ground and the remaining layers were also not well
fastened. More polychromy has survived on the front part of the coat, on
the gures' tunics, the Child's face and less on the hands, the hair, the
almost broken off Madonna's face and the base of the sculpture. Only a
few small paint patches which had survived in the eyelid and the neck
allowed one to establish the Madonna's flesh colour.
As several later paint layers were visible, 24 samples were taken for
stat graphical and chemical analysis. After having carried out paint
cross-section analysis, the five sculpture's overpainting stages were
established. The most important achievement is that the full view of the
original polychromy was restored. It had been very smart. The wood was
covered with 0.1-0.4 mm thick ground of white chalk and glue that had
become yellowish due to the influence of the glue.
The survived ground is in good condition. The tunics of both figures
were silvered with silver leaf. In the course of time the unprotected
silver had blackened. The inner side of the coat was gilded with gold
leaf on red bolus. The Madonna's crown was also silvered and gilded with
imitated precious stones, the colours of which were obtained by covering
the silver leaf with translucent, coloured varnishes.
The original binding material for the polychromy is oil. The pigments
used were lead white, cinnabar, red ochre, burnt umbra, green earth and
charcoal. The flesh colour was pink, the hair was of chestnut colour,
the Madonna's coat and sandals were red and the base of the sculpture
was green.
As it was impossible to establish the full view of the original
polychromy from the obtained results of the investigation, it was
decided to restore it fully and to remove the reminants of later over
painting.
The sculpture was disinfected with the antiseptic "Valaton" and kept in
a disinfection chamber for a week. The pieces of polychromy, which had
flaked off were glued back with rabbit skin glue. The wood damaged by
pests was consolidated with polybutylmetacrylate (PBMA). After fixing of
the polychrome and the consolidation of wood, the layers of over
painting were removed. It was not possible to take them off from the
original paint layer with solvent mixtures because the binding medium of
all the paint layers was the same-oil. The over painting had to be
removed from the original paint layer mechanically using a scalpel, a
needle and controlling the level of cleaning under a magnifying glass.
The solvents were successfully applied while removing the over painting,
which were directly on the wood in the places of the lost polychromy.
After the dirt and the glue surplus were cleaned from the exposed
original polychromy, the holes caused by wood pests were filled and the
missing fragments were carved, the restoration of the missing polychromy
started. The exposed wood was covered with a new chalk and glue ground.
It was retouched with watercolours and gold and silver leaf. A full
reconstruction of the sculpture's polychromy was done, saving original
areas of the polychromy (colour plates 9 and 10). This decision was made
according to the Head of the Church's request.